Cartes-Comparatifs-02-Amex-Scotia-vs-Amex-Verte

Head-to-Head: American Express® Green Card vs Scotiabank American Express® Card

To the point Here's our detailed comparison of the American Express® Green Card and Scotiabank American Express® Card, two no-fee cards designed for travel.

American Express Canada and Scotiabank offer two cards for frequent travelers:

Welcome bonus

The welcome bonus offered by each of these cards varies according to the promotions.

Here is how the current offer is structured:

With this welcome offer from this card , you can earn 10,000 Membership Rewards points:

  • 10,000 points when you charge your card $1,000 in net purchases in the first 3 months following card approval.

Based on our Membership Rewards points valuation (1.7 cents per point), this welcome bonus corresponds to a value of170 $.

With this welcome offer for the Scotiabank American Express® Card, you can earn up to 5,000 Scene+ points:

  • 2,500 Scene+ points after adding $250 to your Card in the first 3 months
  • 2,500 additional Scene+ points by spending a total of $1,000 in the first 3 months

Based on our Scene+ points valuation (1 cent per point), this welcome bonus corresponds to a value of50 $.

Advantage: American Express® Green Card

The American Express® Green Card offer gives many more points and more value than its compatriot.

Minimum income

The American Express® Green Card requires no minimum income.

The Scotiabank American Express® Card requires a minimum annual income of $12,000.

Advantage: American Express® Green Card

Like the vast majority of American Express cards, the American Express® Green Card requires no minimum income.

It should be noted, however, that the Scotiabank American Express® Card is also very affordable, with its low annual income requirement.

If you’re looking for travel benefits, but don’t have a very high income, either of these cards may be right for you.

Annual fee

The American Express® Green Card has an annual fee of $0.

The Scotiabank American Express® Card has an annual fee of $0.

Advantage : Draw

It’s so simple! You won’t need to pay an annual fee for these two cards.

Earning points

The American Express® Green Card and Scotiabank American Express® Card offer different point accumulations.

With the American Express® Green Card, you earn:

  • 1 point per dollar (value of 1.7 cents) on all ;
  • 2 points per dollar (value of 3.4 cents) for purchases from Amex Travel Services online (accommodation and car rental).

The Scotiabank American Express® Card allows you to earn :

  • 3 Scene+ points per dollar (i.e. 3 cents) for purchases at IGA, Rachelle Béry, Les Marchés Tradition, Voilà par IGA, Sobeys, Safeway, Foodland, Thrifty Foods, FreshCo and Chalo! FreshCo;
  • 2 Scene+ points (2 cents) per dollar spent at restaurants, dining, meal delivery, entertainment, grocery stores, gas and public transit ;
  • 1 Scene+ point per dollar (1 cent) for the remainder.
Scotiabank American Express® Card

For everyday spending, the Scotiabank American Express® Card is the best and will give you more.

Redeeming points

Loyalty programs are completely different:

As a result, the way points are used is different.

For travel

With the American Express® Green Card, you can apply its Membership Rewards points to reimburse any travel purchase charged to the card (airline tickets, hotels, Airbnb, car rentals, etc.), where 1,000 points = $10 in reimbursement.

You can also use the American Express fixed rate chart for specific flights.

The redeeming rate is 1,000 points = $20.

Scene+ points and travel:

You can apply them to travel purchases in two ways, thanks to the fixed redemption rate where 10,000 points = $100 credit:

  • Redeem points directly when booking travel with Scene+ Travel, administered by Expedia.
  • Make your own travel purchases as you wish and use your points to pay off the balance on your À la carte Travel card.
Advantage : Draw

The two ways of using points for travel are relatively similar for both cards.

For everyday shopping

With the American Express® Green Card, you can apply Membership Rewards points to everyday purchases charged to the card.

The redeeming rate is 1,000 points = $10.

You need to redeem a minimum of 1,000 points (i.e., a minimum of $10).

You can redeem 1,000 Scene+ points for a $10 discount at the IGA/Sobeys checkout.

Points can also be used to purchase gift cards on the Scotiabank/Scene+ website, from 1,000 to 1,400 points for a $10 discount.

Scene+ points can also be redeemed:

  • 500 points for a $5 discount at selected restaurants (Harvey’s, Swiss Chalet, etc.);
  • 100 points for $1 off movie tickets at Cineplex ;
  • 500 points for $5 off food and beverages at Cineplex, Rec Room and chips at Playdium ;
  • At least 14,500 points for a $100 statement credit on any card expense.
Advantage: American Express® Green Card

With the American Express® Green Card, whether you want to use your points for travel or any other purchase, you’ll get the same value: 1,000 points = $10 less for you to pay.

This is not the case if you want to use Scene+ points for statement credit on anything, where using Scene+ points is not advantageous at all.

Transfers to other programs

With the American Express® Green Card, you can transfer your points to other rewards programs:

You cannot transfer Scene+ points to other programs.

When your Scene+ points are in your Scene+ account, you have no other way out: you can only use them in the Scene+ program.

Advantage: American Express® Green Card

American Express® Green Card Membership Rewards points are highly flexible and can be transferred elsewhere at great savings.

This flexibility is not available with the Scotiabank American Express® Card.

The Benefits

With the American Express® Green Card, you enjoy the following benefits:

  • Card made from 99% recycled plastic;
  • Points redeemable for gift cards, merchandise and purchases on Amazon.ca ;
  • American Express instalment plan to pay for your purchases in monthly instalments.

The Scotiabank American Express® Card offers you the following benefits:

  • Insurance for mobile devices ;
  • Discounts of up to 25% at AVIS and Budget ;
  • Earn 3 Scene+ points for every dollar spent on Scene+ Travel hotel and car rental reservations charged to your card.
Advantage : Draw

It really depends on your lifestyle! It’s up to you to decide which card wins this round.

Insurance

Insurance Green Card American Express scotiabank american express card
Buyer’s Assurance® Protection Plan 1 additional year 1 additional year
Purchase Protection® Plan Up to $1,000
90 days
Up to $1,000
90 days
Mobile Device Insurance Up to $1,000
Advantage: Scotiabank American Express® Card

Insurances are similar, but the Scotiabank American Express® Card has convenient mobile device insurance.

Bottom Line

So? Which Card is the winner?

In the short term, the American Express® Green Card will give you more points up front with its welcome offer.

Over the longer term, the Scotiabank American Express® Card will earn you more points.

The American Express® Green Card is the best for these reasons:

  • Its welcome offer is even more attractive;
  • No minimum annual income required;
  • Its flexible points allow a multitude of possibilities;
  • It has a wide range of airline and hotel partners for transferring points.

The Scotiabank American Express® Card is a good compromise and stands out on its own:

  • Its insurance for mobile devices ;
  • Faster points accumulation.
Come to discuss that topic in our Facebook Group!
4.7 Milesopedia Rating
Caroline Tremblay
I'm Caroline, a loyalty program specialist! I use my points to travel more often and at a lower price with my spouse and our two children. I'm passionate about writing about the latest rewards news and how to put more points in your pocket.

Suggested Reading