What is comprehensive car insurance in Canada?

Fact checked by
Marie-Ève Leclerc
Marie-Ève Leclerc

Marie-Ève Leclerc

Marie-Ève Leclerc
Marie-Ève, Web Director at Milesopedia, is an expert in budget travel and a slow travel enthusiast. Specializing in Aeroplan, Scene+, and Marriott Bonvoy programs, she spends nearly six months a year abroad, making travel her way of life. Constantly seeking the best waves to surf, excellent coffee, and strategies to extend her travels, she is often found in coworking spaces with fellow digital nomads or by the sea, watching the sunset.
All posts by Marie-Ève Leclerc
Achat Voiture 2
To the point You've just bought a car and you're not sure whether to buy basic or comprehensive cover? In this article, we explain why comprehensive coverage is the most popular in Canada.

Comprehensive car insurance is all-inclusive coverage for your vehicle, protecting you against damage with or without collision or upset, including fire, theft, vandalism, weather damage and much more. This article explains what comprehensive insurance is, and how it differs from other types of cover.

Car insurance is mandatory in Canada. However, each province and territory imposes minimum insurance coverage requirements, generally focusing on liability insurance for bodily injury and property damage. We therefore recommend that you familiarize yourself with the rules in force in your area.

What is comprehensive car insurance?

By law, car insurance is mandatory in Canada. Basic coverage includes liability insurance of a minimum of $200,000 (except in Quebec). Other insurance coverages are optional:

  • Collisions or upsets
  • Specific risks (list of risks specified in your insurance policy)
  • Comprehensive excluding collision or upset (fire, theft, vandalism, etc.)
  • Comprehensive (All Risk Insurance)
  • Additional options known as “endorsements” (e.g. replacement value, roadside assistance, car rental insurance, etc.).

As the name suggests, comprehensive car insurance covers all risks. For example, it combines third-party liability insurance, collision and upset coverage, and comprehensive excluding collision or upset (fire, theft, vandalism, windshield replacement, damage caused by bad weather such as hail, etc.) in a single policy.

What are the advantages of comprehensive car insurance?

Although the insurance premium is more expensive, comprehensive car insurance is advantageous because it covers all risks. In fact, it’s the most popular car insurance coverage in Canada. So whether or not you’re at fault in an accident, your vehicle is damaged by natural disasters such as hail or flooding, or you’re the victim of a hit-and-run, you’ve got nothing to worry about. You’re covered!

Quelle est la différence entre l'assurance tous risques et les autres types d'assurance automobile ?

Firstly, collision and upset insurance covers, as the name suggests, damage caused by collision or upset.

Secondly, coverage for specific risks covers a list of risks specified in your insurance policy. However, it does not cover damage caused by collision, fire, theft or vandalism if the risk is not covered.

Comprehensive excluding collision or upset covers damage without collision or upset, such as fire, theft, vandalism, windshield replacement and weather-related damage.

Finally, comprehensive car insurance coverage offers the greatest protection of all policy types. In fact, it combines the protections listed above.

That said, check the conditions and exclusions in your car insurance contract or when comparing car insurance quotes online. If necessary, talk to an insurance agent or broker like YouSet to understand the insurance coverage required for your needs.

How does the comprehensive deductible work?

The insurance deductible is the amount you must pay in the event of an insurance claim. The amount you pay depends on your insurance policy and its conditions. Typically, car insurance deductibles range from $100 to $2,000.

Deductibles generally apply to collision or upset coverage and comprehensive car insurance coverage. You can choose a different deductible amount for each type of coverage. For example, you could choose a deductible of $500 for collisions and upsets, and $100 for all other risks (fire, theft, vandalism).

Does car insurance cover damage caused by an at-fault accident?

As a general rule, physical damage to your vehicle caused by an at-fault accident is covered if you have collision or comprehensive insurance. If you only have basic coverage (liability insurance) or comprehensive excluding collision or upset, your insurer will not cover repairs to your car. In this case, you will have to pay the repair costs yourself.

Do you need comprehensive car insurance?

By law, you must take out third-party liability insurance, the minimum amount of which varies according to where you live. But choosing optional insurance such as comprehensive car insurance depends on your personal and financial situation. If you’ve bought a new car, comprehensive cover is certainly a good option to protect your purchase and drive with a certain peace of mind.

On the other hand, if you drive a low-value used car, or have a budget that allows you to pay for repairs, then comprehensive car insurance may not be the best option for you.

In short, take your personal situation and other factors into consideration to make an informed decision.

How can you reduce your comprehensive car insurance premiums?

There are several ways to reduce your car insurance premiums, such as :

  • Increase your insurance deductible
  • Combine your home and car insurance. For example, with our partner YouSet, you can save up to an additional 15% when you combine your car and home insurance.
  • Get several car insurance quotes and compare them
  • Contact a car insurance broker

To find out more, read our complete guide to car insurance.

Bottom Line

In short, comprehensive car insurance is all-inclusive coverage for your vehicle. It protects you against damage with or without collision or upset, including fire, theft and vandalism. It’s more expensive than basic insurance coverage, but you can drive with peace of mind.

Before taking out a new insurance policy, it’s essential to compare car insurance quotes to find the one that best suits your needs and budget.

What is included in comprehensive car insurance?

Comprehensive car insurance includes third-party liability, collision and upset coverage, and comprehensive coverage for damage caused by fire, theft, vandalism, windshield replacement or natural disasters.

When should buy comprehensive car insurance for your vehicle?

Insuring your vehicle with comprehensive car insurance depends on your personal and financial situation. For example, if you’ve bought a new car, comprehensive cover is a good option to protect your purchase and drive with peace of mind.

How much does comprehensive car insurance cost?

The price of comprehensive car insurance varies according to a number of factors, such as the make, model and year of production of your car, your driving history, where you live, your age and your gender. In some cases, your credit rating is also taken into account when calculating your car insurance premium.

When should you take out comprehensive car insurance?

If you’re planning to buy a new vehicle, you may want to take out comprehensive car insurance to protect your purchase. Consider your personal and financial situation when choosing car insurance.

Come to discuss that topic in our Facebook Group!
Vincent Morin

Vincent Morin

Vincent Morin
Vincent achieved financial independence and retired early (FIRE) at the age of 35. After a career in financial technologies for a large American investment bank, he founded Retraite101, a personal finance site that reaches more than 350,000 unique visitors per year and has more than 30,000 subscribers on social media. Passionate about personal finance, cycling, reading and gardening, he continues to write to inspire and motivate Quebecers to take charge of their finances.
All posts by Vincent Morin

Suggested Reading

Receive our newsletter every week!

Savings are here:

Milesopedia