Comparison: American Express Aeroplan Card vs. TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite
May 11, 2022
To the point
Looking for the best credit card in Canada offering insurance on award travel? Here are the best credit cards.
Table of contents
Credit cards insurance reminder
We can’t repeat it enough: keep the documentation sent with your credit card. This includes the insurance coverage booklet.
Various insurance benefits
Ideally, you have to refer to it before deciding to use this card to book your trip!
Indeed, all credit cards have several coverages related to:
- age of the credit card holder
- insured persons
- destinations
- trip duration
- out-of-province absence duration
- type of car rented (even stating excluded car brands)
- flight/baggage delay duration
But for reward program users, the essential part is the definition of what is a “covered trip.”
Actually, you’ll find there the coverage conditions of your credit card insurance!
Various insurance coverage conditions
Some credit cards will require that you:
- Charge at least 75% or the full trip costs to your Card (read: without using miles and points)
This is the case, for example, with the Scotiabank Passport™ Visa Infinite*:
- Credit Cards Associated Programs
This is the case, for example, with the American Express® Gold Rewards Card: you are covered for a trip paid by redeeming Membership Rewards points earned under the Membership Rewards Program provided any applicable taxes are charged to the Card (but this is not the case when you have redeemed points from another program like Aeroplan or AIR MILES).
While other cards will only require that the full or partial cost of your trip has been charged to the account.
For example, this is a quote from BMO® World Elite®* Mastercard®* Insurance:
General rule: use a card associated with a program
As a general rule, we recommend you to use:
- an AIR MILES credit card to cover an AIR MILES award travel
- an AEROPLAN credit card to cover an AEROPLAN award travel
- a Membership Rewards card to cover a Membership Rewards award travel
- and so on for each program
So, if you use the BMO® AIR MILES® World Elite®* Mastercard®*, you will be covered if there is a problem related to your AIR MILES award travel.
Here is the insurance note of this card regarding award flights booked with miles (AIR MILES in that case):
Special rule: credit cards covering all situations
But with some rare credit cards, you are covered even if you only charge a part of the trip to the credit card!
So you can redeem Aeroplan miles, charge taxes to your credit card and be covered by your credit card insurance!
Four credit cards stand out from the competition in Canada:
- BMO® World Elite®* Mastercard®*
- BMO® AIR MILES® World Elite®* Mastercard®*
- National Bank’s World Elite Mastercard®
- National Bank’s World Elite Mastercard®
With both BMO credit cards, you are covered, in all circumstances, whether the full or partial cost of your trip has been charged to the card.
Regarding National Bank credit cards, you are covered in most of the circumstances, whether the full or partial cost of your trip has been charged to the card. However, baggage delay insurance requires that the full cost of the flight was charged to the card. The same is true for car rental insurance.
On the other hand, coverage will generally be more generous than BMO’s. And an undeniable benefit for people aged between 65 and 74:a medical-hospital insurance coverage outside the province of residence is included.
Note that the Desjardins Odyssey® World Elite® Mastercard has similar insurance to the National Bank’s World Elite Mastercard® ones. However, for most of its insurance, Desjardins’ credit card requires that the full cost o has been charged to the card.
It’s up to you to make your choice based on your needs!
To help you, here are two tables listing the main insurance coverages offered by these credit cards.
BMO Insurance
Here is a summary of insurance coverages of the BMO® World Elite®* Mastercard®* and the BMO® AIR MILES® World Elite®* Mastercard®*.
| Insurance | Coverage |
| Medical/hospital insurance Out-of-province-of-residence |
up to $2,000,000 per person (see details on age and duration) |
| Trip Cancellation Insurance (before departure) |
up to $2,500 per insured person |
| Trip Interruption Insurance (after departure) |
up to $2,000 per insured person |
| Departure flight delay insurance (over 6 hours) |
up to $500 per account |
| Baggage insurance in case of delay (over 12 hours) |
up to $2,000 per account |
| Lost or Stolen Baggage Insurance | up to $2,000 per account |
| Vehicle rental insurance | Vehicle valued up to $65,000
theft of personal effects up to $2,000 |
| Purchase protection in the event of theft or damage (90 days) |
up to $60,000 |
| Extended warranty doubled | up to an additional 1 year |
| Insurance booklet | BMO® World Elite®* Mastercard®* |
The BMO® World Elite®* Mastercard®* and BMO® AIR MILES® World Elite®* Mastercard®* have different coverage for emergency medical care while travelling depending on:
- the person’s age
- the length of the trip
| Age | Maximum trip time frame |
| less than 64 | 21 days |
| 65 to 74 | Optional coverage |
| 75 years or older | no coverage |
You can request to BMO for an optional 31-day Medical Protection.
National Bank Insurance
For most insurance included, the National Bank’s World Elite Mastercard® and the National Bank’s World Mastercard® are among the only credit cards in Canada to cover you even if you only charge to it a part of the cost of the trip.
The following expenses will be reimbursed (…) provided that a portion or the entire cost of the trip was charged to the account
National Bank of Canada
For travel insurance, only baggage insurance in case of delay and vehicle rental insurance requires that the entire cost was charged to the card.
| Insurance | Coverage |
| Medical/hospital insurance Out-of-province-of-residence |
up to $5,000,000 per person (see details on age and duration) |
| Trip Cancellation Insurance (before departure) |
up to $2,500 per insured person |
| Trip Interruption Insurance (after departure) |
up to $5,000 per insured person |
| Departure flight delay insurance (over 4 hours) |
$250 per day (up to $500 per person) |
| Baggage insurance in case of delay (over 6 hours) |
up to $500 per person |
| Lost or Stolen Baggage Insurance | up to $1,000 per person |
| Vehicle rental insurance | Vehicle valued up to $65,000
theft of personal effects up to $2,000 |
| Purchase protection in the event of theft or damage (180 days) |
up to $60,000 |
| Possibility of tripling the manufacturer’s warranty | up to 2 additional years |
| Insurance booklet | National Bank’s World Elite Mastercard® |
The National Bank’s World Elite Mastercard and the National Bank’s World Mastercard® offer different levels of protection for Out-of-province-of-residence medical/hospital insurance according to:
- the person’s age
- the length of the trip
| Age | Maximum trip time frame |
| 54 and under | 60 days |
| 55 to 64 | 31 days |
| 65 to 74 | 15 days |
| 75 years or older | no coverage |
Conclusion
As always, we advise you to carefully read each credit card’s insurance booklet before making a decision. Don’t hesitate to contact your credit card issuer for clarification if in doubt.
Here are posts you can check out about specific credit cards insurance:
- What you need to know about travel insurance for people 65 and over
- Review: The Best Credit Cards Offering Insurance On Award Travel
- How does theft and damage insurance for credit card rental cars work?
- How does credit card trip cancellation/interruption insurance work?
- How does the extended warranty offered with credit cards work?
- Credit Card Flight Delay Insurance
Come to discuss that topic in our Facebook Group!
